"A chief operating officer at a mid-size technology company recently described her return-to-office rationale with unusual candor. "We don't actually know if the work is getting done well," she said. "We know it's getting done. We just can't tell if it's excellent or mediocre until something blows up. When people were in the building, I could walk a floor and know within ten minutes which teams were thriving and which were drifting. I lost that.""
"But the productivity data never supported that framing. Bureau of Labor Statistics research from October 2024 found a positive relationship between the rise in remote work and total factor productivity across 61 industries in the private business sector. A 2024 randomized control trial led by Nicholas Bloom found that hybrid work (two days at home) had zero negative effect on worker productivity or career advancement."
"My employer Gallup's engagement data showed no systematic decline when people worked from home. If the work was getting done, what problem are return-to-office mandates actually solving? The uncomfortable answer is the one that COO articulated: many organizations struggle to measure what their teams actually accomplish independent of physical presence. The mandate is less about restoring collaboration and more about restoring the confidence that comes from visual verification of work happening."
Many organizations cannot reliably distinguish between adequate and exceptional work without in-person observation. Leaders often cite culture, collaboration, and innovation to justify return-to-office mandates, but productivity research does not support those claims. Bureau of Labor Statistics research found a positive relationship between remote work and total factor productivity across 61 private-sector industries. A randomized trial led by Nicholas Bloom found hybrid work had no negative effect on productivity or career advancement. Gallup engagement data showed no systematic decline when people worked from home. The primary effect of office mandates is restoring managers' confidence through visual verification rather than measurably improving collaboration or output.
Read at Forbes
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]