Matt Chapman or Robbie Ray? Which current Giant should Blue Jays have kept longer?
Briefly

Both Matt Chapman and Robbie Ray had opportunities to extend their careers with the Toronto Blue Jays but chose not to. During their time, they contributed to separate playoff appearances, with Ray assisting in the 2020 postseason run and Chapman participating in 2022 and 2023. Despite individual accolades, such as Chapman’s Gold Glove in 2023, their performance was mixed, with both facing offensive challenges. After leaving, both found new success with the San Francisco Giants, raising questions about Toronto's decision to let them go.
Chapman was a three-time Gold Glove winner before joining Toronto, earning the award in 2023, the first for a Blue Jay since 1990.
Chapman struggled offensively during his time with the Blue Jays, hitting 27 home runs in 2022 but striking out 170 times.
Robbie Ray joined the Blue Jays mid-way through the 2020 season and helped the team reach the postseason during his tenure.
Ray left Toronto after the 2021 campaign, illustrating the impact of both players leaving during crucial moments in their careers.
Read at Jays Journal
[
|
]