What the culture war over Superman gets wrong | Noel Ransome
Briefly

Superman, characterized as an immigrant, emerges as a symbol discussing broader themes of race, belonging, and kindness. James Gunn's comments sparked significant backlash, with critics alleging that he politicized the character. Despite these criticisms, they overlook Superman's historical stance against fascism since 1941. The outrage reflects a discomfort with the portrayal of kindness in an increasingly divided America. The characterization of Superman and his immigrant narrative invokes discussions about the nature of identity within superhero stories and their connection to American values.
Superman has always represented the immigrant experience, a symbol of kindness amidst the turmoil of American identity, raising debates about race and belonging.
James Gunn called Superman the story of America, emphasizing his immigrant background and inherent kindness, which some interpreters found politically charged.
Dean Cain criticized James Gunn's portrayal of Superman as politicized, disregarding the character's longstanding critique of fascism since 1941.
The backlash against viewing Superman as an immigrant reflects a wider denial of America's multicultural identity and the enduring nature of superhero narratives.
Read at www.theguardian.com
[
|
]