Keir Starmer's plan to implement sanctions against people-smuggling networks operating in the Channel has received skepticism from experts in security and immigration. David Lammy announced efforts to target corrupt police, fake passport dealers, and small boat suppliers. Critics like Tom Keatinge warn that overpromising may mislead expectations, while Dr. Peter Walsh noted a lack of evidence concerning the effectiveness of similar EU sanctions. Overall, doubts persist regarding operational details and demonstrable outcomes in significantly disrupting smuggling activities.
Tom Keatinge, the director of the Centre for Finance and Security, cautioned against overpromising regarding the use of sanctions to target people-smuggling gangs, suggesting that such strategies could hold governments to fortune.
David Lammy stated that the sanctions regime aimed to tackle the impunity of criminal gangs preying on vulnerable people, describing it as the first of its kind globally.
Dr. Peter Walsh highlighted the lack of high-quality evidence regarding the impact of sanctions on people smugglers, referencing the EU's similar sanctions scheme that has shown little effectiveness.
Historical context reveals that promises to disrupt smuggling networks with sanctions remain to be seen, reflecting skepticism from various security and immigration experts regarding the feasibility of such measures.
Collection
[
|
...
]